14. I had this situation on a few occasions. This is aged group players who are at the club but who haven't yet come through the intake. Let's look at the very 1st intake I have come across in this experiment, (I have holidayed to this point in Brazil). In terms of CA, the L20 Training Facilities performed only slightly better than the min facilities test. and what seemed strange to me is that the preview with the highest rating of B was still a golden generation, but Preview (with just 1 A rating), wasn't classed as a golden generation. 15. In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's, players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? * It's important to differentiate between what we know and what we think so I will always try to be clear when something is just my opinion rather than something which I think is a fact and not up for debate. Regarding this, there are two range of dates that the game seems to use: We werent able to determine if geographical location has anything to do with countries being placed in one or another, but knowing the dates should be enough. 6. I could do 100 or 1,000 but I just don't have the ability/knowledge to automate the reports that this would require. I recently saw a Youtube video from [Name redacted], (because this isn't about them), about Youth Intakes and I was absolutely astonished by some of the rubbish that was being spouted. From what I have seen I don't have any issue with his stuff being posted in here. No offer of a new contract as yet so I'm browsing the job centre! I don't have the CA and PA numbers on, as much as I don't know how as any other reason. Highest PA 167. 5. If you aren't playing competitive football by the time you are 23 you should be asking yourself if you are at the right club (imo). 10 gives us an idea at least. Im mostly done in like year 2040 after real players expire theyre careers. Best position/role. If the econ factor changes ofc you need to improve the background of yout intake in some lets say next 10 years. In my opinion the Ajax thread is the best FM related thread on these forums, (had to be specific because the OTF guys get funny), and even though it's hugely out of date now, I still urge anyone who hasn't read it to go and read it, and maybe even if you have read it, go back and read it again. So I will admit to being particularly curious as to what the results would show here. This stat affects the order in which Youth Intakes happen for loaded leagues, even: weve noted that the clubs with the best Youth Recruitment within a country will receive their regens first. So don't worry so much about actual CA and PA, (never mind about PCA and PPA). That probably gives the best of both worlds if you have good training facilities to help them too. But I've got two players. With tighter budgets across the board in Football Manager 2022, innovating with. 9 out of the 10 intakes were classed as golden generations, and what seemed strange to me is that the preview with the highest rating of B was still a golden generation, but Preview (with just 1 A rating), wasn't classed as a golden generation. 1. The 1st thing I'm going to up in the Editor is Training Facilities. 8 players at 120+ PA. The next thing I want to so is run this intake 9 more times to see what sort of return we get from 10 previews. 3. The staff that can be selected for the entry for Bring youth players into the club and inform you of their development is. Highest CA 118. I have added this to the list on page #6. Now, pick any youth from the first ones generated and you can get yourself some of the best youth players in the world. What can change? Youth Intake Challenge FM23 Article posted on Football Manager Challenges for Football Manager 2023 Login Register FM23 . (This is immediately subjective because it depends if you are looking at CA or PA). The first thing you need to know is that every country has two fixed hidden attributes. A weird single intake was observed in June. 18+ - game time is more important, so if you aren't playing them in first team games at least 15 minutes a game, better to send them on loan to a level where they will get game time. Clubs with high youth recruitment ratings are often the clubs that get the best youth intakes. after their name is a potential star and I have to put the work in with them. broward health medical center human resources phone number. (We know that the attributes change, including the hidden attributes, so it makes sense this would be fluid too). The truth is that you need to think what you want out of them and when you want it by, and then sort of reverse engineer it backwards so that you give them the development that will get them there. Surface Studio vs iMac - Which Should You Pick? 3. We were expecting 32 in total, (so 16 approx in each section). FM Mythbusting: Youth Intakes Published on 10 April 2020 One of the most exciting days in the Football Manager calendar is the day when your club's youth intake arrives. Check our Top Heads of Youth Development shortlist! The staff at the club. Now obviously this is what I "think" (or more accurately, what I've heard) rather than provable fact, but from what I understand, the development priorities are: <18 - training is more important for development, so if you have better facilities it's better to keep them in youth squad for their development (assuming not good enough to play, at least as sub for first team). A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. Total CA/PA for the whole intake is definitely something I will add. We've already calculated that based on the laws of probability, we should expect to see something like 32 occurrences of this in each section so how many have we got? What it does, (accurately or not is debatable), is give you an overview of the intake at this preview stage and tell you if it's any good or not. I currently have a 17 year old right back who has a PA of 155 and as well as 30(1) appearances for the B Team, he has already played 16(1) appearances for the 1st Team. Because my current save is a second attempt at the Alex Ferguson challenge. But it is useful to know a country's youth rating for other purposes, such as scouting and nabbing youth players from other clubs. Step 1 - How to find FM 2021 regen youth intakes Create a shortlist and name it 'Youth Intake'. I appreciate someone doing the research on this though, enjoying the work so far. The picture above is lies. Instead, sign players who are in their prime, and you will see an almost immediate impact. Best FM22 Wonderkids FM22 Players Under 25 FM22 Transfer Budgets FM22 Youth Facilities Graphic Megapacks Cut Out Facepack V2023.06 - 10 Feb 2023 . If you want to learn more about coach quality, I suggest reading our Training Guide. 13. From your first post regarding intake depth. Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. I will add it to the list. 6. It was largely due to their combined talent, that Dynamo had its period of greatest domestic and international success. Is it hard work? It doesn't matter which club I select because I'm going to use the Editor to change things in order to see how they impact on the Youth Intake. In terms of your question (17.) Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Range is 1-200. Highest CA 91. Especially the part of different favoured persons, since it might mean my "ignore actual abilities and focus on personality/media handling" for all staff members might be proven to be a good idea (or not, as it were). PCA. Allow me to introduce Ricardo to you, and his 9 alter-ego's. You can also supplement your youth intake by recruiting more established young players on professional contracts as part of a general youth focus. Just because I "think" something doesn't mean that my mind is closed to the idea of me being wrong. It contains a comprehensive list of potential people that are fit for the position based on the exact same values we just went over. Or can the same player count for more than one? There's a quick and easy way to find this out. If you see a player you like, you may be able to sign them for free, creating your own factory for talented wonderkids. Like I said though, my understanding in this area is pretty weak so.. further investigation required again. My 1st choice striker in Portugal is a bloke called(32g) Ramos (POR). Likely more game time, but lower standard of everything else. When you get to the Championship or the Premier League, you can then turn your attention to maximizing the potential of your youth system. Highest PA 161. I will also document what the facilities are for this intake and also what the HoYD is like at this time. 12. 14. Youth Recruitment is a club's network of information and ability to recruit young prospects. great work jim really interesting to read. Then my main question around youth intakes and player development has always been the same. Yes of course there is a balance to be had here and if you play a player too much too young, then the chances are he will pay a price at the back end of his career. Just for the sake of putting it on record and to confirm that I have checked it, I will also list the things that are fluid and change from save to save. 15. It's certainly doable and is something I have thought about before. 15. 8. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you have to go to Club Info, Facilities and you'll see your level of Youth Recruitment at the bottom. If you are trying to add regens to your shortlist from multiple intake months this may not work due to size, you need to do each month individually. Depending on the strength of your current squad, the youngsters might have a range of 3 to 5 stars on their potential. One of the clubs had intake Mid-November. Where the player has multiple positions where he has natural ability, then what decides which 1 is used as the "preferred role" is unknown, but as the report is coming from the HoYD, (in this case), rather than from the player, I think it's reasonable to assume that it's the HoYD's "opinion" on what the players preferred role should be. You can take a guess of which countries have the highest game importance, e.g Argentina, Brazil, Germany, Spain, etc. Head of Youth Development. Will be reading this with great interest. We were expecting something close to 32 and we actually got 82, (256% bigger than we expected). Let's list some of the things that we know influence player development. We don't have a HoYD, but this is the bloke in charge of the intake. 12. 5 players at 150+ PA. A golden generation means that the staff in charge of bringing youth into your U18 team thinks there are three or four players from the youth intake that have the potential to feature in the first team in the coming years. The clubs with the best overall youth potential will get their Youth Intake first. Highest PA167. As a helpful guide, here's the youth intake date (or date ranges) for every top nation in the game: Click here for everything we know about FM22. IE the screenshot of the pitch with the positions and the number of players in each. @OlivierL. It definitely isn't fluid now). The dream is for a 'golden generation' of youth and, even better than that, a player that "could possibly emerge as one of the best players of his generation." Spoiler alert - you won't always get good players. Another hidden attribute and linked to countries, just like youth rating. Interested in poaching the best Heads of Youth Development the game has to offer? Manage Settings There was a suggestion that all the facilities have 10 levels and another suggestion that some had 10 levels and some had 8 levels. Highest PA 167. What happens if I reduce/increase the club reputation both before preview and after? Today, Jake takes a look at how you can improve youth intakes in FM2023 so you can. The Football Manager 2023 winter transfer update includes a number of essential changes to the FM23 database. I know I certainly am. To increase your reputation you have to win leagues and cups. I don't think I have used the pre-game editor since the CM days, (it was a long time ago anyway), so while I know roughly what the -10, -9, -8 etc is, I would find it very hard to explain to someone else in this thread for example. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. If I was to give my opinion it would be that U23 experience should be greater than U19 experience, (but not by loads), and it's the reason many U23's go out on loan. Giggs, Scholes, Butt and both Neville's never did. Freeze Player Attributes. Then you open up that inbox message There may have already been experiments to test this, although I'm not sure exactly how you might do so. content may be reproduced without permission. First intakes are sometimes Golden Gens because the player takes it over and starts making massive improvements, so the new players coming are better. Click on the drop down menu, open the Facilities tab, and select "Improve Youth Facilities". (Except for penalty taking. In order to unlock 'Golden Generation,' you must win a domestic league with a squad that includes at least four players who came through the ranks at your club after you took charge. Just to confuse things further, normal order is resumed for Youth Recruitment where Adequate again comes before Average. 4. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. What happens if I edit the Training Facilities/Youth Facilities both before the preview and after? Before I get into the next experiment, I had a conversation with a few people recently with regards to the different levels within the facilities. 7 players at 120+ PA. day to find the players you want like last year. FM22 Youth Intake Tips | Increase Your Chances of a Golden Generation in Football Manager 22 - YouTube FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. class="algoSlug_icon" data-priority="2">Web. owners. So the info here comes from his ability to judge players, (both in terms of CA and PA). 142-187 fits between the -85 and -9 ranges so. further investigation required I think. 7 players at 120+ PA. It is commonly believed that the 1st intake of each save, (for all clubs), is boosted for some reason. A high PA young player with decent CA is likely to be a decent candidate for staying at the club and playing senior football. When you decide to upgrade, you can see the cost of upgrading by going to finances and then expenditure. Football Manager 2022 is here, which means it's time to dust off your suit and tie and get ready for another rollercoaster season. 26.24Control Group Average PA. 73.09Minimal Facilities Average PA. 33.01. This is simply an error that SI made when these levels were introduced, but for whatever reason they have decided not to correct the order in Junior Coaching. The chances are that you will already know how the (Pro), (Amb) & (Det) tests turn out, but the Morale thing is a little different so might be worth checking out. Nothing else have changed. RealSport101 is supported by its audience. Don't get me wrong, he turned out ok, but he was well short of his PA in the end, (CA 123 PA 158 right now). Though to me it seems to have an air of self fulfilling prophecy about it. I "think" it's too simplistic to say that there is a cut-off like that, but without running an experiment it's hard to quantify, and I would expect the results of any experiment in this area to be open to significant amounts of interpretation, (which is not really the idea). When we're looking at the CA and PA of players, every CA and every PA must end in either a 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 or 10, (even if they are single digit numbers). Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. Is the loan system pushed by the in game engine because its replicating the real world? Before I tell you what affects your youth intake, it's better you understand how they're made in the first place. Is it possible for a player to have more than one preferred role? you can check out this one about comparing development. Thanks. Then there are the players who are good enough to play in theLiga Portugal 2 SABSEG, so I send them out on loan to another Liga 2 side. Something that's important to remember at all times when talking about Youth Intake previews and Youth Intakes themselves is that everything is relative. Powered by Invision Community. I think it would help to see the total PA & CA of the intakes as well as the basic number of players. This is the message as it appears in my inbox, but rather than scrolling through the other positions, instead I'm going to click on Dev Centre - Youth Candidates and it makes things easier to view. I have a little trick that I use and it involves putting a "." FM22 Youth Intake Tips | Increase Your Chances of a Golden Generation in Football Manager 22 - YouTube FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. (The personality has to change because all the personalities are variable). I have seen players develop 3 gold star PA and higher, and one of these is a first-team squad player for me now in Darren Brook. Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? He's found the back of the net on 8,944 occasions and provided a remarkable 2,926 assists - that works out at a direct goal contribution every two games. This "preferred" position will ALWAYS 100% of the time be 1 of the Natural Ability positions. We know that each player only appears once on the Intake Distribution graphic, (as evidenced above), but we don't know what makes them get allocated into these specific positions. 10. It's really not an exact science I'm afraid. This one will be particularly interesting for me. Or does it mean the position that the HoYD, (because he's compiling the report remember), thinks that the player wants to play in. This group were so good that they were all asked to train with the senior squad early on and all impressed. Media description. RIght? Let's just ignore the 1st Team squad because they won't play for the B Team anyway, but after them we have the players who are good enough to play for a Liga Bwin side but who are not good enough to get in our 1st Team so they go out on loan. Some Lower Division got intake in Late December. 5 players at 150+ PA. A couple intakes were observed in October. Youth intake day signals the arrival of 'newgens' - players that were not previously in the game but have been generated and enrolled by SI. Absolutely nothing is static. As a second point, but also an addendum, when we refer to top clubs, we dont necessarily mean so in terms of quality or reputation, but in terms of Youth Recruitment. Even clubs like Ajax, Barcelona and Manchester United famed for their youth system rarely promote 2 or 3 players each year who can consistently feature in their first team. Highest PA 179. Get the best HoYD . Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.com. It had almost 100,000 views and more than 1,900 likes and it was full of absolute rubbish. One of the largest Football Manager Communities/Forums on the internet. Two First Division teams had intake Mid-November. PPM's. Even though you know they are not the same, you might be surprised by quite how different they can be. 4 players at 140+ PA. When you consider that the overall level of the Facilities was 23 compared to 4, this doesn't see like a good investment for this purpose, (but then again, you wouldn't think it would be). They are convenient, environmentally friendly, and relatively affordable. 19. Football Manager 2022 - Youth Intake Guide, How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake, Free-transferrable Players (by 2021) Shortlist. Deciding who goes in what squad and making sure that there aren't too many players in their position in that squad and that they aren't either too good or not good enough for that squad is tough when you have so many players. 5 players at 150+ PA. As we have seen, the golden generation tag given to a youth intake is largely tied to the quality of your first team. Just like in the real world, it is just not realistic to have potential superstars coming out of your youth system each year. A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. Sign up for a new account in our community. That is, any of your U23, U20, etc coaches. We have Average CA and Average PA for each player on the far right. You're correct though. It doesn't matter what the numbers are. 7. We know for sure that Game Importance plays a role in your youth intake's potential ability, but we do not know exactly what it does. I'm playing Youth Only and messing about with my GK upfield and not mentoring players in order to make the game more of a challenge. The 1st thing to do will work out when the intake it, (it's towards the end of April), create a save before the date of the intake and go from there. It's not my channel, but something which I like to watch. That's a flippin enormous failure in my book. In the same vein, your head of youth development might get the potential of your youth intake wrong. One is called Game Importance and the other one is Youth Rating. That way I can do a little bit of this and then return to playing my own save and then come back and do a little bit of this again. with that kind of honed in searching, finding a quality player to fill your team's needs should be doable. It's easy! Improving youth recruitment, youth facilities, and hiring a top head of youth development will undoubtedly lead to fruitful results on youth intake day. Initially I posted a reply to the video, (and no I'm not going to link to it in here), but I deleted my post and instead of telling you what I know and what I think, I'm going to run some experiments and let the results speak for themselves. I can't begin to tell you how beneficial I have found the B Team. I'm not sure that Geographic location will be used like this, but then again it seems pretty reasonable. The last true golden generation for Dynamo Kyiv was incidentally also a class of 92-93. Highest CA 94. The chances are we will lose him, (by about age 26/27 at the latest I think), and I need to have other options because I can't just go out and buy someone to replace him. It's only 14 mins long and he deals with 4 slightly different topics and even came up with a conclusion that surprised him, so rather than ignoring it or just blindly accepting it, (he was using quite a small sample size), he actually created a test to work out if the experiment was correct or if his initial assumption had been correct all along. It could mean 5 or 6 players expected to feature as key players in the youth team for 2 years. This section is also useful if you want to track Transfers, just dont change the filter and thats that. (I must admit that I had to work out how to sum every 2nd column just for this thread, so every day's a school day as they say). This is because you are now getting reports from one of your coaches, who might have a different opinion on the players ability compared to the scout. Yes, I thought we had, but that was for FM22 and what did I say at the very start of the thread? 1. Actually the real PA from this intake isn't as far removed from the PA star rating. If you're lucky enough to be good enough to get a chance in our team then you get exposure to all the factors that would serve as a catalyst for advancing high potential. Henrique Simal. Trademarks and brands are the property of their respective I "think"* what happens now is that the player rates your player against the player at your club best able to play in that position, (and how good he is in that position rather than how good he is in his best position). i tried this with many teams as i wanted to check whether this works or not. This is what I "think" rather than what I "know" though. If you are on twitter then bookmarking this tweet might be of help, (at least until Elon turns the lights out). There's no statistical information because it's a youtube video and I guess that would be boring, so it's presented as some findings. I don't mind Youtubers telling us what they think, (and even getting things wrong occasionally), but I do mind them peddling blatant lies. Jimbokav1971, May 31, 2022 in Challenges, Sign-Ups & Experiments. Highest CA 95. What happens if I edit the Affiliations, both before the preview and after? The truth here is that there isn't a 1 size fits all answer, quite simply because there is not only 1 thing that influences player development. You can play the game for thousands of hours without ever having a golden generation of your own while on the other side, you can get it in the first season of a different save. All rights reserved. For example I'm sure there are absolutely LOADS of people who are unaware that Average/Adequate on Junior Coaching is the wrong way round. 82? 7 players at 120+ PA. You can leave this for last if you're struggling for money. I've actually found it really challenging trying to manage the different squads in this save. Fair play, you're right that I may have remembered that from a previous version and it's all changed since then. Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? These will increase the prospect of a 'golden generation' or two for your club, but you won't get quality players every. For a start there isn't a lot of info there, and I complained for quite a while that the information it did contained had very little, (if any), direct impact on the Youth Intake itself, (although it appears as if those issues have now been resolved and the preview is indeed a snapshot into what will be coming you way later in the season). Honestly, it makes me flippin angry when people in the FM Community make a video about something that they know very little about, and then pass it off as if they are some sort of expert or have some sort of insider knowledge that the rest of us don't have access to. 8 players at 120+ PA. Just go with your gut, because CA and PA lie! What we do know is that it will be the position, or 1 of the positions in which the player where the player has "Natural" ability. Developing our youngsters into world beaters brings an almost unparalleled sense of satisfaction, and FM21 gives us more control over the youth development process than ever before. Once you sign the player, the stars might then drop to 3 or 4. At the moment I'm just sticking a few through just to get it started. If you look at post 2, you will see that there are 10 different Youth Intake previews.